NARA Discovery
Article Details
← Back to Search Results
Journal Article

Enferplex bovine TB antibody test and bovine TB diagnosis: letter to the editor

Neil Watt; Alastair Hayton; Keith Cutler; Amanda O’Brien; John Clarke; Gordon D. Harkiss
Veterinary Research Communications · Vol. 48, Issue 1 · pp. 603-606 · 2024

Abstract

Bovine tuberculosis is usually diagnosed using tuberculin skin and interferon gamma tests. However, it is clear these tests miss infected animals due to poor sensitivity. The Enferplex Bovine TB antibody test has been validated by the World Organisation for Animal Health as fit for purpose in diagnosing bovine TB. A recent paper by Madden and colleagues (Veterinary Research Communications published online 17 August 2023) presented data on the future risk of Enferplex test antibody positive animals developing bovine TB. We argue in this communication that this does not make sense. Also, the study design did not include measuring antibodies at the point of censure of the animals and hence the survival analysis performed was meaningless. Most significantly, the study misses the point that skin and interferon gamma tests fail to detect a significant proportion of infected animals identified by the Enferplex test.

Bibliographic Information

JournalVeterinary Research Communications
PublisherSpringer
Publication Date2024-02-01
Publication Year2024
Volume48
Issue1
Pages603-606
Document TypeJournal Article
Print ISSN0165-7380
eISSN1573-7446
DOI10.1007/s11259-023-10229-4

Access Information

NARA Access Coverage1977-01-01~Current
Journal Homepagehttps://www.springer.com/journal/11259
Publisher PageOpen Publisher Page
Full-text access depends on NARA's subscribed coverage and institutional access.