Coral Reef Community Structure and Photophysiology Differ Between Upwelling and Non-Upwelling Locations on the Pacific Coast of Costa Rica

Abstract

Reef-building corals and coralline algae form the calcium carbonate frameworks that underpin tropical coral reefs, yet in some locations, coral cover has declined by ~50% in recent decades due to marine heatwaves and other stressors. Identifying refugia environments, such as upwelling systems, that may buffer stress, promote recovery, and could enhance resilience by promoting physiological plasticity that supports thermotolerance is therefore critical. Here, we compared benthic community composition, coral percent cover, and photophysiology between an upwelling location in the Gulf of Papagayo and a non-upwelling location in Sámara on the Pacific coast of Costa Rica. Waters in Papagayo were cooler, more acidic, and had higher chlorophyll-a concentrations. Reefs at this location exhibited higher crustose coralline algae, higher sea urchin abundance, and lower macroalgae cover, compared to Sámara. Papagayo also showed higher stony coral cover, driven by Pocillopora spp., while Sámara was dominated by massive, heat-tolerant Porites spp. Photophysiological parameters were significantly different between locations. Specifically, photosynthetic efficiency (Fv′/Fm′) was 10–45% higher, and maximum photosynthetic rate (Pmax) was 20–40% lower in corals from Papagayo than in those from Sámara. These results reveal that two locations differing in environmental regime within a relatively small geographic area also differ in coral community composition and photophysiological features. Although further research is needed to resolve whether these environmental contrasts shape the observed biological differences, the observed patterns are consistent with the hypothesis that such regimes may support reef persistence or refugia, providing a basis for future work to test this hypothesis directly.

Bibliographic Information