Abstract
Most insect herbivores specialize on a few host plants; however, there are a minority of highly generalized species capable of feeding on hundreds of hosts. Generalism could emerge as a property of the species as a whole, while individuals would still exhibit greater specialization at more specific organizational levels. Yet, we lack studies with generalist insect herbivores directly testing this prediction. Here, we test if the highly generalized fall webworm ( Hyphantria cunea ) maintains its broad diet through specialization at the population, maternal genotype, or individual level. We reared two populations and multiple matrilines on either a static or rotating diet of four host plants. We found that both populations survived and pupated on all hosts, suggesting population‐level generalization. We found evidence for generalization at the genotype level, as maternal genotypes did not vary in performance rankings across host plants. Finally, we found generalism at the individual level, as individuals reared on a rotating diet had no difference or showed intermediate performance to those reared on static diets. Overall, we found support for the maintenance of generalism across all levels, suggesting that generalist species need not be locally specialized to maintain their extremely broad diet.