Abstract
Ecological theory predicts that the relative distribution of primary production across habitats influence fish size structure and biomass production. In this study, we assessed individual, population, and community-level consequences for brown trout ( Salmo trutta ) and Arctic char ( Salvelinus alpinus ) of variation in estimated habitat specific (benthic and pelagic) and total whole lake (GPP whole ) gross primary production in 27 northern oligotrophic lakes. We found that higher contribution of benthic primary production to GPP whole was associated with higher community biomass and larger maximum and mean sizes of fish. At the population level, species-specific responses differed. Increased benthic primary production (GPP Benthic ) correlated to higher population biomass of brown trout regardless of being alone or in sympatry, while Arctic char responded positively to pelagic primary production (GPP Pelagic ) in sympatric populations. In sympatric lakes, the maximum size of both species was positively related to both GPP Benthic and the benthic contribution to GPP Whole . In allopatric lakes, brown trout mean and maximum size and Arctic char mean size were positively related to the benthic proportion of GPP Whole . Our results highlight the importance of light-controlled benthic primary production for fish biomass production in oligotrophic northern lakes. Our results further suggest that consequences of ontogenetic asymmetry and niche shifts may cause the distribution of primary production across habitats to be more important than the total ecosystem primary production for fish size, population biomass, and production. Awareness of the relationships between light availability and asymmetric resource production favoring large fish and fish production may allow for cost-efficient and more informed management actions in northern oligotrophic lakes.