A Finite Element Analysis Comparing an Additive Manufacturing Lattice-Structured PEEK Implant to a Commercial Ball-and-Socket Design for Cervical Total Disc Replacement

Abstract

Purpose Cervical total disc replacement (TDR) is commonly performed to treat degenerative cervical spondylosis, but it often faces challenges such as implant wear and migration. This study aimed to develop and evaluate a novel 3D-printed TDR featuring a titanium endplate and a lattice-structured poly-ether-ether-ketone (PEEK) design. The primary objective was to replicate the natural motion of the cervical disc while addressing complications associated with conventional TDRs. Methods The novel implant was created using additive manufacturing techniques, incorporating three lattice-structured PEEK designs (Cross, Octet, and Ventiles) for the nucleus pulposus and annulus fibrosus components. A finite element analysis was conducted to compare the biomechanical performance of the novel TDR with an intact cervical disc and a commercially available TDR (Baguera®C, Spineart SA, Geneva, Switzerland). Key parameters, including maximal von Mises stresses, range of motion, paths of the instantaneous center of rotation, and facet joint stresses, were evaluated under physiological loads (100 N follower load and 1.5 Nm pure moments). Results The novel 3D-printed TDR maintained structural integrity, with stresses remaining within the yield strength of PEEK. The biomechanical performance closely resembled that of an intact cervical disc, demonstrating similar ranges of motion, instantaneous center of rotation paths, and facet joint stress distributions. Conclusion The findings indicate that the innovative 3D-printed TDR may restore normal cervical spinal kinematics more effectively than existing commercial options, potentially reducing the risk of post-operative facet joint syndrome. Further experimental and clinical studies are recommended to validate these results.

Bibliographic Information