Selection against recombinant hybrids maintains reproductive isolation in hybridizing Populus species despite F 1 fertility and recurrent gene flow

Abstract

Natural hybrid zones have proven to be precious tools for understanding the origin and maintenance of reproductive isolation ( RI ) and therefore species. Most available genomic studies of hybrid zones using whole‐ or partial‐genome resequencing approaches have focused on comparisons of the parental source populations involved in genome admixture, rather than exploring fine‐scale patterns of chromosomal ancestry across the full admixture gradient present between hybridizing species. We have studied three well‐known European ‘replicate’ hybrid zones of Populus alba and P. tremula , two widespread, ecologically divergent forest trees, using up to 432 505 single‐nucleotide polymorphisms ( SNP s) from restriction site‐associated DNA ( RAD ) sequencing. Estimates of fine‐scale chromosomal ancestry, genomic divergence and differentiation across all 19 poplar chromosomes revealed strikingly contrasting results, including an unexpected preponderance of F 1 hybrids in the centre of genomic clines on the one hand, and genomically localized, spatially variable shared variants consistent with ancient introgression between the parental species on the other. Genetic ancestry had a significant effect on survivorship of hybrid seedlings in a common garden trial, pointing to selection against early‐generation recombinants. Our results indicate a role for selection against recombinant genotypes in maintaining RI in the face of apparent F 1 fertility, consistent with the intragenomic ‘coadaptation’ model of barriers to introgression upon secondary contact. Whole‐genome resequencing of hybridizing populations will clarify the roles of specific genetic pathways in RI between these model forest trees and may reveal which loci are affected most strongly by its cyclic breakdown.

Bibliographic Information